2026 Top Rated Rhode Island DUI Attorney
Free Consultation

CALL

EMAIL

TEXT

Field Sobriety Tests in Rhode Island in 2026: How They Work and How They Fail

Field Sobriety Tests in Rhode Island in 2026: How They Work and How They Fail

Field sobriety tests in Rhode Island are roadside exercises an officer asks a driver to perform before deciding whether to make a DUI arrest. They produce observations, not a number. No Rhode Island statute requires a driver to perform them, and declining them is not a chemical test refusal under R.I. Gen. Laws § 31-27-2.1. What the officer writes about them, though, often becomes the backbone of the police report.

This guide explains how field sobriety tests in Rhode Island are given and scored, how they differ from the preliminary breath test and the chemical test at the station, and why they are so often challenged in court. Rory Munns defends DUI cases across Rhode Island from his office at 127 Dorrance Street in Providence.

What Happens Before the Roadside Tests

An officer needs a specific reason to stop a car, such as speeding, a lane violation, or an equipment problem. Rhode Island does not allow DUI checkpoints. The Rhode Island Supreme Court held them unconstitutional in Pimental v. Department of Transportation in 1989, so every DUI stop has to stand on its own facts.

Once the car is stopped, the officer watches and listens. The report usually lists the odor of alcohol, speech, eyes, how the driver handled the license and registration, and any statement about drinking. Those notes are used to justify asking the driver to step out for roadside tests.

The Three Standardized Tests

The standardized roadside battery comes from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. It has three parts. Each test is supposed to be explained and demonstrated the same way every time and scored against a fixed list of clues.

Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus

The officer moves a pen or small light side to side and asks the driver to follow it with the eyes only. The officer looks for jerking of the eyes and for eyes that do not track smoothly. The training lists 6 clues, 3 for each eye. The speed of the stimulus, its distance from the face, flashing lights, and fatigue can all affect what the officer sees, and some medical conditions and medications cause similar eye movements.

Walk and Turn

The driver stands heel to toe while the officer gives instructions, then takes 9 heel to toe steps along a line, turns in a set way, and takes 9 steps back. The training lists 8 clues, including losing balance during the instructions, starting too soon, stopping, missing heel to toe, stepping off the line, using the arms for balance, a wrong turn, and the wrong number of steps. Knee, back, and ankle injuries, footwear, and a sloped or gravel surface all affect the result.

One Leg Stand

The driver raises one foot about 6 inches off the ground and counts out loud until told to stop. The training lists 4 clues: swaying, using the arms for balance, hopping, and putting the foot down. Age, weight, inner ear problems, cold, and wind make this test hard for many sober people.

Tests Outside the Standard Battery

Some officers also ask for the alphabet, finger counting, or touching a finger to the nose. These are not part of the standardized battery, and they have no standard scoring. A defense lawyer will ask why they were used and what they are supposed to show.

Why Field Sobriety Tests Fail as Evidence

The basic problem is that nobody knows how the driver would have done on the same tests sober, on the same road, in the same shoes, at the same hour. The report records a conclusion, and the conclusion can sound more certain than the scene was.

  • Instructions are given once, outdoors, often over traffic noise.
  • Sloped pavement, gravel, rain, cold, and passing headlights affect balance and focus.
  • Injuries, medical conditions, and medications may never be asked about.
  • Nerves make hands shake and speech uneven.
  • Scoring is a judgment call, and two officers can count different clues.
  • The written report and the cruiser or body camera video do not always match.

That last point is often the heart of the defense. Video shows the surface, the lighting, the instructions, and the actual performance.

Field Tests, the Roadside Breath Test, and the Station Test

Three different things can happen at a Rhode Island DUI stop, and each has its own rules.

Field Sobriety Tests

These are physical exercises. No statute requires them, and declining them is not a refusal under § 31-27-2.1. The officer can still write down what was observed before and during the request.

The Preliminary Breath Test

Under R.I. Gen. Laws § 31-27-2.3, an officer with reason to believe a driver is under the influence may ask for a roadside preliminary breath test. Its result can be used only to guide the arrest decision and as evidence of probable cause for the arrest. It cannot be used as evidence of guilt in a DUI or refusal proceeding. Refusing the preliminary breath test is an infraction with a $100 fine under § 31-41.1-4, and a medical condition that prevented the test is a defense.

The Chemical Test After Arrest

After an arrest, the officer can ask for a chemical test of breath, blood, saliva, or urine. Refusing that test is a separate charge. A first refusal is a civil violation heard at the Traffic Tribunal with a $200 to $500 fine, 10 to 60 hours of community service, a 6 month to 1 year suspension, a $500 highway safety assessment, and a $200 Department of Health assessment. A second refusal within 10 years is a misdemeanor, unless the test refused was a blood test. The breathalyzer refusal laws in Rhode Island page covers those penalties.

What to Do at the Roadside

Pull over safely, keep your hands visible, and hand over your license, registration, and insurance when asked. Stay polite. You do not have to guess about your own condition or describe how much you had to drink, and you can say you would rather not answer questions. The what to say when police question you guide covers the words to use.

After the stop, write down what happened while it is fresh: the surface, the weather, your shoes, any injury, what the officer said, and what you were asked to do.

How Rory Munns Challenges Field Sobriety Evidence

Rory Munns starts with the report and the video. He compares how the officer described each test with what the recording shows, checks whether the instructions and demonstrations matched the standard, and looks at the surface, lighting, and the physical condition of the driver. He also asks whether the stop was lawful and whether the officer had probable cause to arrest. When the roadside evidence is weak, that can affect the arrest, the chemical test that followed, and the whole case.

Call Rory Munns About Your Field Sobriety Tests

The report and the video already exist, and the sooner they are reviewed the better. Call 401-573-2265 any time, day or night, for a free consultation. Rory Munns is a Providence DUI lawyer with an office at 127 Dorrance Street, next to the Garrahy Judicial Complex.

Related Reading

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to do field sobriety tests in Rhode Island?

No Rhode Island statute requires a driver to perform roadside field sobriety tests, and declining them is not a chemical test refusal under § 31-27-2.1. The officer can still rely on other observations, such as driving behavior, odor, and speech, when deciding whether to arrest.

Is a roadside breath test the same as a field sobriety test?

No. The preliminary breath test is a handheld device covered by § 31-27-2.3. Its result can only support probable cause for the arrest, not prove guilt at trial. Refusing it is an infraction with a $100 fine. Field sobriety tests are physical exercises with no statute requiring them.

How accurate are field sobriety tests?

They are indicators, not measurements, and they produce no number. Their value depends on correct instructions, a fair surface, and a driver with no physical limits. Injuries, footwear, weather, and nerves can all affect performance, which is why the video and the notes of the officer get close review.

Can a DUI be dismissed if the field tests were done wrong?

It can help. If the tests were given or scored improperly, the officer may not have had probable cause to arrest, and evidence that followed can be challenged. Whether that leads to a dismissal depends on the rest of the evidence in the file.

Does Rhode Island use sobriety checkpoints?

No. DUI checkpoints have been illegal in Rhode Island since the state Supreme Court decided Pimental v. Department of Transportation in 1989. Every DUI stop needs its own specific reason.

This article is general information about Rhode Island law and is not legal advice for any specific case. Speak with a lawyer about the facts of your own situation.

Field Sobriety Tests in Rhode Island in 2026: How They Work and How They Fail2026-10-24T00:38:09-04:00